(2020-11-14, 01:54 PM)jonno Wrote: Would this be a good place to ask if a decent copy of Thriller has appeared anywhere?
So I had a quick look at what I've got.
I have the NTSC LaserDisc versions of HIStory and HIStory volume II en route, and I have the PAL DVD versions of both. I figured that since these were shot on film, the PAL discs would theoretically be good sources to have, since *theoretically* it would be sped up from 24 to 25 fps, interlaced, and potentially duplicate whole frames or maybe just fields would be added to keep sync without having to speed up and pitch shift the audio (which seemingly is fine for films but unacceptable for music videos).
But looking at the Thriller from the PAL DVD copy of HIStory, there are combed frames all over the place. Not only that, but it also has that characteristic analogue video noise look that I get from my LD captures off my newest player (the one that I like the least for that very reason). Just about every damn frame has combing throughout. I'm wondering, therefore, if this PAL DVD might be a conversion of a capture of the NTSC LaserDisc, or perhaps of the PAL LaserDisc but the PAL LaserDisc was previously converted from NTSC (badly). I guess it wouldn't be wild to shoot something like this on film but then edit it on tape, so the master may not have been the film scan but rather the edited tape master, which would logically have been NTSC with a 60/1.001 field rate.
So... I guess now I'm looking for the NTSC DVDs to see if they're a more viable source.
Sometimes I wish I had less expensive hobbies, you know that?