Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
[Help] Do you lose EX when editing 5.1EX?
#1
Maybe a dumb question here...  If I want to edit the 5.1EX DD (first coverting it to wav files), will I lose EX after I render it out as 5.1 pcm when done? I guess you don't since the EX is encoded into the rear surrounds with an algorithm. Or am I wrong?
Reply
Thanks given by:
#2
You're not wrong! Same thing with matrixed Lt+Rt. You kinda *can't* remove the matrix encoding, it's inherent to the bitstream.
Reply
Thanks given by: allldu
#3
Thanks, I thought so!
Reply
Thanks given by:
#4
(2020-12-08, 11:14 PM)allldu Wrote: Thanks, I thought so!

Although maybe this is worth clarifying just because you said "render out to PCM": the decoder potentially isn't going to know that those surrounds are meant to be matrix-decoded (or upmixed, if you prefer) if you don't encode it back to a format that explicitly marks those channels as matrixed. So if you want to make sure it actually extrapolates out that extra centre surround on playback, you'd want to encode it to something like DTS-ES or Dolby Digital EX. I've never encoded Dolby EX but I have encoded DTS-ES just fine. It might depend on your AVR what it does if you just leave it as 5.1 but set it up with the 6.1 ES/EX speaker layout though, you might find that it just does that for every 5.1 track by default.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#5
(2020-12-08, 11:26 PM)pipefan413 Wrote:
(2020-12-08, 11:14 PM)allldu Wrote: Thanks, I thought so!

Although maybe this is worth clarifying just because you said "render out to PCM": the decoder potentially isn't going to know that those surrounds are meant to be matrix-decoded (or upmixed, if you prefer) if you don't encode it back to a format that explicitly marks those channels as matrixed. So if you want to make sure it actually extrapolates out that extra centre surround on playback, you'd want to encode it to something like DTS-ES or Dolby Digital EX. I've never encoded Dolby EX but I have encoded DTS-ES just fine. It might depend on your AVR what it does if you just leave it as 5.1 but set it up with the 6.1 ES/EX speaker layout though, you might find that it just does that for every 5.1 track by default.

So speaking generically, there must be a set up EX flag for the AVR to read the 5.1EX correctly, unless you're able to push the button on this said AVR yourself?
Reply
Thanks given by:
#6
Also, how do you set ap an EX/ES flag exactly?
Reply
Thanks given by:
#7
You need a professional Dolby Digital encoder to enable the EX flag.

Someone correct me if I'm mistaken but I don't think any of the freeware encoders offer it.

As already noted in this thread, even if the EX flag is not enabled, one can still manually set EX decoding and get the same result.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#8
(2020-12-09, 03:31 AM)Wisp of Smoke Wrote: You need a professional Dolby Digital encoder to enable the EX flag.

Someone correct me if I'm mistaken but I don't think any of the freeware encoders offer it.

As already noted in this thread, even if the EX flag is not enabled, one can still manually set EX decoding and get the same result.

Precisely.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#9
(2020-12-09, 03:31 AM)Wisp of Smoke Wrote: You need a professional Dolby Digital encoder to enable the EX flag.

Someone correct me if I'm mistaken but I don't think any of the freeware encoders offer it.

Aften has the EX flag option.
Sadly my projects are lost due to an HDD crash... Sad
Fundamental Collection | Vimeo channel | My blog
Reply
Thanks given by: pipefan413 , allldu
#10
(2020-12-09, 04:25 AM)spoRv Wrote:
(2020-12-09, 03:31 AM)Wisp of Smoke Wrote: You need a professional Dolby Digital encoder to enable the EX flag.

Someone correct me if I'm mistaken but I don't think any of the freeware encoders offer it.

Aften has the EX flag option.

Thanks for the tip. Any good online guide of how to work with Aften? I found GUI, but somehow cannot render out the 5.1 AC-3...
Reply
Thanks given by:


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Editing Subtitles With Movie alleycat 3 588 2020-09-30, 01:44 PM
Last Post: alleycat
  Editing DTS-HD Master Audio without transcoding Kreeep 8 2,679 2020-09-13, 08:15 AM
Last Post: Kreeep
  Editing - Still "bit-perfect"? spaceboy710 5 1,216 2020-07-12, 03:01 PM
Last Post: BusterD
  [Help] Editing Atmos track allldu 2 823 2020-05-20, 09:08 PM
Last Post: allldu
  Editing mkv files Serums 2 2,047 2018-06-21, 08:46 AM
Last Post: Serums
  Video editing software FrankT 4 2,334 2018-03-24, 02:41 AM
Last Post: FrankT
  Subtitles Converting and Editing PDB 12 9,675 2016-07-29, 03:39 PM
Last Post: Feallan

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)