Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Was 1917 ever broadcast in open matte?
#1
Just curious to re-live that IMAX experience.
New, low or non-posting members: Please do not post or PM me asking where to get something or what the current status of a project is. Such requests are ignored. Instead, stick around and become a participating member. Thank you.

Reply
#2
I saw it twice: once in IMAX then once in 2.39:1. I felt like 90% of it was definitely framed for 2.39:1 and the IMAX version basically just looked like film that was supposed to be matted but wasn't, which sucked, because I really love full on IMAX.

And then of course there's this... https://www.rogerdeakins.com/film-talk/1...ase-dates/

[Image: emersive.png]

But certainly for some of the grander shots it's amazing. As with THE FORCE AWAKENS, for instance, it's an excellent way to frame "character running away from explosions"; seeing smoke / dirt / whatever flying high into the air and still fitting inside the frame the whole time is really nice.

I'm not entirely sure what he's talking about re. IMAX's "silver screen" here https://www.rogerdeakins.com/post-the-di...nd-standa/... I assume this is a standard thing for IMAX theatres that I didn't know about?
Reply
Thanks given by:
#3
Some 3D screens are silver to maintain the polarity of the L/R images
Reply
Thanks given by: pipefan413
#4
(2021-02-09, 02:27 AM)zoidberg Wrote: Some 3D screens are silver to maintain the polarity of the L/R images

Ah. I don't think 1917 was IMAX 3D though, just IMAX... I wonder if maybe that's the problem, they need to be able to exhibit 3D so use silver screens and that annoys him.

Anyway, don't mean to derail; I would like to be able to see it open matted again as well, and I think for this film it might be cool to create a fan edit that selectively opens the frame only at specific moments. Controversial, I know. I think the variable AR thing actually helps accentuate those moments where the height works, personally; that moment in one of the Mission: Impossibles where they started in 2.39:1 and the frame grew to 1.9:1 was genuinely thrilling for me and I hate that you can't see it at home.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#5
No worries. Deakins has been very clear that the 2.39 version of Skyfall, BR2049 and 1917 are the official versions. So I respect his wishes in that regard. And you do get a lot of dead space in the open mattes although I think that worked well in 2049. But still the “open matte” aka IMAX aka 1.90, etc is an official version that I’d like to see again.

I had a friend check local US cable and it’s OAR and that seems to be the case for broadcasts the rest of the world. I thought maybe like 2049 there would be an om on vod or something.
New, low or non-posting members: Please do not post or PM me asking where to get something or what the current status of a project is. Such requests are ignored. Instead, stick around and become a participating member. Thank you.

Reply
Thanks given by: pipefan413
#6
(2021-02-10, 01:48 AM)PDB Wrote: No worries. Deakins has been very clear that the 2.39 version of Skyfall, BR2049 and 1917 are the official versions. So I respect his wishes in that regard. And you do get a lot of dead space in the open mattes although I think that worked well in 2049. But still the “open matte” aka IMAX aka 1.90, etc is an official version that I’d like to see again.

I had a friend check local US cable and it’s OAR and that seems to be the case for broadcasts the rest of the world. I thought maybe like 2049 there would be an om on vod or something.

Yeah, though I honestly felt Skyfall was pretty breathtaking in IMAX (more so than 1917). Like I'd take IMAX framed Skyfall over 2.39:1 Skyfall any day of the week. But I think there's definitely strong evidence that 1917 was not really framed for IMAX at all, it just coincidentally happens to look fine occasionally.

That's a bummer. Maybe one day, I suppose...
Reply
Thanks given by:
#7
I know I'm speaking the obvious here, but it continues to confound me that these films with high-profile alternate formats don't have them subsequently recaptured on home video.

Even Nolan's IMAX material gets truncated (unless you count the separately-released footage from Interstellar and TDK). Wouldn't the inclusion of an IMAX format disc be an enormous draw for home cinema enthusiasts?

Side note: 1917 at the BFI IMAX was my last 'normal' cinema visit. I did go to see Tenet locally but, you know.
Reply
Thanks given by: pipefan413
#8
(2021-02-10, 12:01 PM)jonno Wrote: I know I'm speaking the obvious here, but it continues to confound me that these films with high-profile alternate formats don't have them subsequently recaptured on home video.

Even Nolan's IMAX material gets truncated (unless you count the separately-released footage from Interstellar and TDK). Wouldn't the inclusion of an IMAX format disc be an enormous draw for home cinema enthusiasts?

Side note: 1917 at the BFI IMAX was my last 'normal' cinema visit. I did go to see Tenet locally but, you know.

You and me both.

It was almost my last cinema visit but not quite: saw The Invisible Man and Dark Waters a few days after 1917. So Dark Waters would be my last one methinks.

Was really annoyed that I couldn't see Tenet in IMAX (still haven't seen it at all yet). And Bond tickets were preordered with Cineworld...
Reply
Thanks given by: jonno
#9
Deakins rightly doesn't like DMR so just opens the matte
Reply
Thanks given by:


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
Exclamation OPEN MATTE - Master List spoRv 181 146,938 2021-06-30, 10:17 PM
Last Post: Nfsfan83
  [versions] [LIST] DVDs with both widescreen and open matte versions Stamper 18 1,361 2021-06-13, 06:21 PM
Last Post: shamar
  Star Wars - open matte spoRv 21 13,341 2021-05-26, 07:41 PM
Last Post: vbangle
  Arrival 2016 open matte wintertime4054 5 817 2021-02-25, 08:08 PM
Last Post: wintertime4054
  [Help] Shaun of the Dead 16:9 Open Matte? TomArrow 16 8,529 2019-09-06, 07:06 PM
Last Post: maksnew
  Point Break (1991) Open Matte - Recommendations?? DeafYakuza 13 4,826 2019-07-22, 09:59 PM
Last Post: Stamper
  Iron Man (2008) Open Matte Bobson Dugnutt 18 11,832 2019-04-05, 03:27 AM
Last Post: OsidianDawn
  Alien Resurrection Open matte DVD? PDB 28 19,311 2019-03-16, 06:48 PM
Last Post: deblock
  Spider-Man 2 (2004) Open Matte Bobson Dugnutt 1 5,052 2018-07-02, 06:34 PM
Last Post: spoRv
  Open Matte wishlist of sorts boots1985 2 2,615 2018-01-15, 11:57 PM
Last Post: Bigrob

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)