Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
[In progress] Big Trouble In Little China (1986) [Project: Celluloid — Regrade]
#1
Hello everyone, just wanted to post that I am not dead but have been merely very busy lately. My free time, simply put, is dwindling so I don't get as many opportunities to work on my projects, however I do want to give a status report of sorts with the creation of this thread.

I've been hard at work for the past few months trying to regrade the European master of Big Trouble In Little China (with many issues arising, forcing me to restart from scratch essentially three times) and I thought it'd be a nice tease for what's to come as well as a means of getting feedback as I am currently pressed with a little issue of sorts.

I'm currently trying to determine what'd be a better approach for this project, attempting to recover more details in the shadows and highlights at the cost of lowering the image contrast and mood to a certain extent or present a regrade more true to the 35mm source I'm working off of (which still holds more details in both ranges I may add but less explicitly).

Higher Contrast | Lower Contrast
[Image: De-Cont-3-25-1.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-25-2.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-74-1.png]
 [Image: De-Cont-3-74-2.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-211-1.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-211-2.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-218-1.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-218-2.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-240-1.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-240-2.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-244-2.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-244-3.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-258-1.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-258-2.png]

[Image: De-Cont-3-307-1.png] [Image: De-Cont-3-307-2.png]

Which would y'all say is better?

I think the higher contrast looks fine on my display, but I seem to find that the rule of thumb is that usually when it looks good to my eyes it looks too crushed to someone else's.

I'm also curious to hear how it looks to those who've seen the movie projected as the saturation has been unintentionally boosted after altering with the regraded footage in Resolve to boost shadows and retain some highlight detail (as the straight LUT crushed and clipped a lot of data given the print source's original contrast), leading to a lot of scenes with richer blues than expected (with a fair amount of gamut clipping in some areas that I'm certain will be pulled back on the encoding stage through some AVS limited palette commands; I've also already applied a bit of saturation compression in Resolve to help).
[Image: ivwz24G.jpg]
Reply
Thanks given by: Hitcher
#2
Both are fine to me, I’d be happier with either choice you make.

But if I had to make a choice, I lean towards the lower contrast version just because it’s a good split between the color and mood of the 35 and seeing more details from the BD.
New, low or non-posting members: Please do not post or PM me asking where to get something or what the current status of a project is. Such requests are ignored. Instead, stick around and become a participating member. Thank you.

Reply
Thanks given by: LucasGodzilla
#3
I prefer the lower contrast, but the highlights seem a bit dim, especially on the skin. I tried to fix one in Photoshop, compare the highlights on her cheeks.

https://i.imgur.com/jzd3f5L.png
Reply
Thanks given by: LucasGodzilla
#4
Agree with everyone else, lower contrast. But to be sure, maybe you could post a small sample clip of both so we can see them in motion to be sure.
Reply
Thanks given by: LucasGodzilla
#5
(2021-08-31, 03:23 PM)bronan Wrote: I prefer the lower contrast, but the highlights seem a bit dim, especially on the skin. I tried to fix one in Photoshop, compare the highlights on her cheeks.

Yeah, the highlights is something I'm trying to figure out the best approach in trying to make the most of the Euro master's highlights which appears to hold more information than the Fox master—which clip a lot of highlights outright—but it's rather compressed, forcing me to figure out a way to stretch it down so-to-speak to showcase more of it.

Experimenting with some alterations in the HDR wheel grading settings, here's what I have now.

Untampered Highlights | Dimmed Highlights V2

[Image: High-3-220-1.png] [Image: High-3-220-2.png]

[Image: High-3-249-1.png] [Image: High-3-249-2.png]

[Image: High-3-Bright.png] [Image: High-3-Dim.png]

Which of the two is "better", I don't know as it looks fine to me in either case, I just know some people out there prefer the highlights to be pulled back a bit to showcase a smidge more detail in the upper range. I will stick with the lower-contrast edit though for the shadows since that seems to be the consensus.
[Image: ivwz24G.jpg]
Reply
Thanks given by: Johnno
#6
Both look good to me, but the lower contrast is nice for retaining details, and probably gives the best balance. Regarding the hilights, I don't see much different either and they both look fine to me also, You're not going to have much more hi-light information to pull out with a SDR master anyway. Just me two cents. Thanks for all the hard work.
Reply
Thanks given by: LucasGodzilla
#7
Lower contrast looks preferable, though I can't tell the difference at all between the untampered highlights and dimmed highlights. So take that with a grain of salt.

Here's to the Army and Navy and the battles they have won; here's to America's colors, the colors that never run.
Reply
Thanks given by:


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  [In progress] TERMINATOR 2 Blu-ray regrade to 35mm Beber 6 243 2021-09-13, 02:55 AM
Last Post: Plissken1138
  The Crow (LD-1st gen DVD Regrade) PDB 27 1,310 2021-08-14, 12:46 AM
Last Post: weegee2392
  [In progress] Hellraiser (1987) [Project: Celluloid] LucasGodzilla 109 38,686 2021-07-20, 11:18 PM
Last Post: Onti
  [In progress] Quick project: The Dead Pool (1988) in Super 35 Stamper 8 510 2021-06-23, 10:45 PM
Last Post: BDgeek
  Event Horizon (LD-1st gen DVD Regrade) PDB 7 547 2021-06-23, 01:06 PM
Last Post: alexpeden2000
  [In progress] Zack Snyder's Justice League - Regrade TomArrow 23 2,126 2021-04-01, 08:42 PM
Last Post: TomArrow
  [Almost ready] The Matrix 4K Regrade sanjuro_61 17 3,007 2021-03-11, 08:17 PM
Last Post: Hitcher
  Indio 1989 & Indio 2 The Revolt 1991 Antonio Margheriti Project alleycat 1 1,772 2021-02-28, 03:35 PM
Last Post: Nicky90
  Dragonslayer Video Fix (Project CRT #5 v1.0) PDB 31 19,486 2020-12-02, 12:01 AM
Last Post: PDB
  The Blade Runner Regrade Collection (Restored DC and IC Regrade v2.0) PDB 208 123,691 2020-07-01, 03:04 PM
Last Post: PDB

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)